If you spend any time around Anhydrous Ammonia, you know how easy it is to detect its presence; however, if you have ever tried to find the leak causing the issue, it can be extremely difficult. One method that is by far the most common, most simple, and one of the easiest and cheapest methods is the use of sulfur (or sulfur) sticks. These things have been around facilities handling ammonia for generations, and I am not even sure of the full history of them, but I can attest to their effectiveness and ease of use. But as a safety professional, I have some concerns with their use and wide acceptance as the "only method that makes sense to locate leaks."  I will frame up my concerns using the OSHA minimum compliance requirements. Now I am in NO WAY suggesting these devices NOT be utilized, but using them comes with some level of risks and advantages; so I am just trying to start the discussion by asking the questions and trying to use a situation as a learning experience that is much more than just about the use of sulfur sticks.

Here is a scenario to consider... A leak has been identified by odor, and in order to find the exact leak point, operators use sulfur sticks, which require the stick(s) to be lit using an open flame. My questions:

Comments   

+1 #1 Jerry 2013-08-12 15:14
Sometimes people think things are black and white issues but not in this case. A sulfur stick is for finding MINOR leaks. Any major leak with a PPM level high enough to cause an explosion would cause the sulfur stick to be useless before the technician would even get close. That's a good reason why you don't hear about sulfur stick accidents.

You have no rights to post comments

 
View 's profile on LinkedIn

 

 LinkedIn Group Button

facebookIcon

 

Partner Organizations

 Chlroine Institute Logo 100 years

I am proud to announce that

The Chlorine Institute and SAFTENG

have extended our"Partners in Safety" agreement

for another year (2024)

CI Members, send me an e-mail

to request your FREE SAFTENG membership

 

RCECHILL BW

  

kemkey logo

OHS Solutions logoCEMANE power association logo

 EIT LOGO

 

Member Associations

ASME logo

 

Screen Shot 2018 05 28 at 10.25.35 PM

aiche logo cmyk highres

Chlorine institute

 nfpa logo.5942a119dcb25

 

TOCAS

 

BLR Logo 2018

 

 

 

 

safteng man copy

 

 organdonor